The analysis of policy convergence, or: how to chase a black cat in a dark room
نویسندگان
چکیده
Political science research on policy convergence has largely remained inconclusive. While many studies found support for the convergence hypothesis, an almost equally large number of studies rejected it. Convergence thus could be a less general phenomenon than many theorists believe. This article identifies a second possible explanation. The variance approach, which dominates political science research on policy convergence, is likely to lead to wrong inferences. Analysing various artificially generated convergence processes, we find that neither the variance approach nor the coefficient of variation detects convergence when it is conditional or when theoretically unidentified convergence clubs exist. Our analysis suggests that researchers should estimate rather than measure convergence. By estimating convergence researchers may (a) test the causal relationship, (b) account for conditional convergence, (c) control for the existence of convergence clubs, and (d) examine convergence to an equilibrium level of a policy.
منابع مشابه
Beyond the Black Box Approach to Ethics!; Comment on “Expanded HTA: Enhancing Fairness and Legitimacy”
In the editorial published in this journal, Daniels and colleagues argue that his and Sabin’s accountability for reasonableness (A4R) framework should be used to handle ethical issues in the health technology assessment (HTA)-process, especially concerning fairness. In contrast to this suggestion, it is argued that such an approach risks suffering from the irrrelevance or insufficiency they war...
متن کاملAchieving a “Grand Convergence” in Global Health by 2035: Rwanda Shows the Way; Comment on “Improving the World’s Health Through the Post-2015 Development Agenda: Perspectives From Rwanda”
Global Health 2035, the report of The Lancet Commission on Investing in Health, laid out a bold, highly ambitious framework for making rapid progress in improving global public health outcomes. It showed that with the right health investments, the international community could achieve a “grand convergence” in global health—a reduction in avertable infectious, maternal, and child deaths down to ...
متن کاملStrong and $Delta$-convergence theorems for total asymptotically nonexpansive mappings in CAT(0)
In this work we use the Noor iteration process for total asymptotically nonexpansive mapping to establish the strong and $Delta$-convergence theorems in the framework of CAT(0) spaces. By doing this, some of the results existing in the current literature generalize, unify and extend.
متن کاملW-convergence of the proximal point algorithm in complete CAT(0) metric spaces
In this paper, we generalize the proximal point algorithm to complete CAT(0) spaces and show that the sequence generated by the proximal point algorithm $w$-converges to a zero of the maximal monotone operator. Also, we prove that if $f: Xrightarrow ]-infty, +infty]$ is a proper, convex and lower semicontinuous function on the complete CAT(0) space $X$, then the proximal...
متن کامل